Betelgeuse Merely Burped, Astronomers Conclude

The dramatic dimming of the red supergiant in 2019 was the product of dust, not a prelude to destruction, a new study has found.,

Advertisement

Continue reading the main story

Betelgeuse, to put it most politely, burped.

In the autumn of 2019 the star, a red supergiant at the shoulder of the constellation Orion the Hunter, began to dim drastically to less than half its usual brightness, and some astronomers worried — or perhaps were hoping — that it would explode in a supernova.

Astronomers now say that dust was the culprit in the Great Dimming and that Betelgeuse itself was responsible for that dust. A giant blob of gas erupted from the star, the story goes, and then cooled off and condensed into solid particles that temporarily veiled their origin.

“We have directly witnessed the formation of so-called stardust,” Miguel Montarges, an astrophysicist at the Paris Observatory, said in a statement issued by the European Southern Observatory. He and Emily Cannon of Catholic University Leuven, in Belgium, were the leaders of an international team that studied Betelgeuse during the Great Dimming with the European Southern Observatory’s Very Large Telescope on Cerro Paranal, in Chile.

Parts of the star, they found, were only one-tenth as bright as normal and markedly cooler than the rest of the surface, enabling the expelled blob to cool and condense into stardust. They reported their results on Wednesday in Nature.

The research, they said, shows that such dust formation can occur very quickly and near a star’s surface. From there it can wind up anywhere; as the old saying goes, we are all made from stardust.

“The dust expelled from cool evolved stars, such as the ejection we’ve just witnessed, could go on to become the building blocks of terrestrial planets and life,” Dr. Cannon said in the statement.

Video

Cinemagraph
Observations by the European Southern Observatory’s Very Large Telescope in January and December 2019 reveal the fading of the star Betelgeuse, and changes to its shape.CreditCredit…By Eso/m. Montarges Et Al.

Their new results would seem to bolster findings reported a year ago by Andrea Dupree of the Harvard-Smithsonian Center for Astrophysics and her colleagues, who detected an upwelling of material on Betelgeuse in the summer of 2019.

“We saw the material moving out through the chromosphere in the south in September to November 2019,” Dr. Dupree wrote in an email. She referred to the expulsion as “a sneeze.” She and Dr. Montarges were co-authors on each other’s papers.

But Edward Guinan, of Villanova University, who has followed Betelgeuse intently, was more measured in this enthusiasm. Three other studies favor the growth of cool regions on the surface of the star to explain the significant decrease in light.

Betelgeuse is a so-called red supergiant, 887 times as large as our own sun. Its surface, like the sun’s, resembles boiling oatmeal as blobs of gas rise, conveying heat and energy. Such blobs on the sun are often described by American astronomers as comparable in size to Texas.

“In France, we say that the sun’s convective cells are as big as France,” Dr. Montarges said in an email. “It’s really funny to see each country comparison.”

But on Betelgeuse, he said, those blobs are half as wide as the star itself, 350 million miles across. There are only a few of them at any given time.

Betelgeuse also undergoes a 400-day cycle of pulsation, dimming and brightening, although usually not nearly to the extreme it just exhibited.

Dr. Montarges and Dr. Cannon began to observe Betelgeuse in 2019 with a special instrument called SPHERE on the Very Large Telescope, which allowed them to follow changes on the surface of the distant star in high resolution.

“For once, we were seeing the appearance of a star changing in real time on a scale of weeks,” Dr. Montarges said in his statement. In late 2019 they observed that one part of the star was only one-tenth as bright as it had been the year before and about 300 to 500 kelvin — 80 to 440 degrees Fahrenheit — cooler than the rest of the star.

Dr. Montarges and his colleagues reason that the boiling star ejected a blob of gas months if not years before the Great Dimming. The gas cloud was about as big as the star. It hung around Betelgeuse as gas because the region around the star was still too warm for the cloud to condense into dust until the next cycle of shrinkage and cooling.

“Then the photosphere cooled,” Dr. Montarges noted, “probably in the initially bright region that ejected the clump.” That would have lowered the ambient temperature in the cloud enough for dust to nucleate and shroud its birthplace.

“This adventure with Betelgeuse was really exciting,” Dr. Montarges said.

And so, for now, Betelgeuse is back to normal — whatever “normal” means to a star on the brink of doom. That the star will eventually blow up is certain. Betelgeuse, pronounced “beetle-juice” and also known as Alpha Orionis, is at least 10 times and maybe 20 times as massive as the sun. If it were placed in our solar system, it would engulf everything out to Jupiter’s orbit.

Red supergiants are stars in the last violent stages of their evolution. Betelgeuse has already spent millions of years burning primordial hydrogen and transforming it into helium, the next lightest element. The helium is burning into more massive elements. Once the core of the star becomes solid iron, sometime within the next 100,000 years, the star will collapse and then rebound in a supernova explosion, probably leaving behind a dense nugget called a neutron star.

That will be quite a show. The last bright supernova in our galaxy was occurred in 1604 and was as bright as Venus in the sky, Dr. Guinan said.

He said that he still glanced at Betelgeuse every day but that lately he had become convinced that an even larger supergiant known as VY Canis Majoris is more likely to blow first.

“I have been observing since 1980,” he said, “and I am now 79 and don’t have much more time left to see these supernovae.”

Leave a Reply